SYNOPSIS: This paper addresses human capital (HC) challenges facing the public company auditing profession. In my opinion, the HC challenges facing the profession make it less likely that the profession can effectively serve the interests of the investing public in the future, and I believe that we must consider fundamental changes to our educational model if these challenges are to be adequately addressed.

In the sections below, I consider the quantity and quality of accounting graduates, the quantity and quality of new accounting and auditing faculty, and a potential educational solution to the HC challenges facing the profession. To the extent possible, I cross-reference my identification of HC challenges to the Advisory Committee on the Auditing Profession’s discussion outline (see http://www.treas.gov/offices/domestic-finance/acap/agendas/outline-10-15-07.pdf). I hope that these comments will provide useful input to the Advisory Committee’s deliberations and will promote additional analysis and debate regarding the future of the auditing profession.

Allen
A.
, and
Woodland
A.
2006
.
The 150-hour requirement and the number of CPA exam candidates, pass rates, and the number passing
.
Issues in Accounting Education
21
(
3
)
:
173
193
.
American Accounting Association (AAA), APLG/FSA Doctoral Education Committee
.
2007
. Report of the Joint AAA/APLG/FSA Doctoral Education Committee.
Sarasota, FL: AAA
.
American Assembly
.
2003
. The Future of the Accounting Profession.
103rd American Assembly. Leesburg, VA: The American Assembly, Columbia University
.
Billiot
M-J.
,
Glandon
S.
, and
McFerrin
R.
2004
.
Factors affecting the supply of accounting graduates
.
Issues in Accounting Education
19
(
4
)
:
443
467
.
Boone
J.
, and
Coe
T.
2002
.
The 150-hour requirement and changes in the supply of accounting undergraduates: Evidence from a quasi-experiment
.
Issues in Accounting Education
17
(
3
)
:
253
268
.
Cumming
J.
, and
Rankin
L.
1999
.
150 hours: A look back
.
Journal of Accountancy
187
(
April
)
:
53
58
.
Davis
G.
, and
Kim
H.
2007
.
Business ties and proxy voting by mutual funds
.
Journal of Financial Economics
85
(
August
)
:
552
570
.
Deloitte
.
2007
. Deloitte Foundation Accounting Doctoral Student Survey.
Available at:
http://aaahq.org/temp/phd/Deloitte_PhD_Survey2007summer.pdf
.
Hasselback
J.
2007
. Analysis of Accounting Faculty Birthdates.
Available at:
http://aaahq.org/temp/phd/JimHasselbackBirthdateSlide.pdf
.
Kaplan
S.
, and
Rauh
J.
2007
.
Wall Street and Main Street: What contributes to the rise in the highest incomes? Working Paper No. 13270. Cambridge, MA: NBER
.
Ketz
E.
2004
.
The accounting cycle: The future of auditing firms. Article at:
http://accounting.smartpros.com/x44334.xml
.
Nelson
I.
,
Vendrzyk
V.
,
Quirin
J.
, and
Allen
R.
2002
.
No, the sky is not falling: Evidence of accounting student characteristics at FSA schools, 1995–2000
.
Issues in Accounting Education
17
(
3
)
:
269
287
.
Plumlee
D.
,
Kachelmeier
S.
,
Madeo
S.
,
Pratt
J.
, and
Krull
G.
2006
.
Assessing the shortage of accounting faculty
.
Issues in Accounting Education
21
(
2
)
:
113
125
.
Raghunandan
K.
,
Read
W.
, and
Brown
C.
2003
.
The 150-hour rule: Does it improve CPA exam performance?
Managerial Auditing Journal
18
(
1/2
)
:
31
38
.
Wier
B.
,
Stone
D.
, and
Hunton
J.
2005
.
Does graduate business education contribute to professional accounting success?
Accounting Horizons
19
(
2
)
:
85
100
.
This content is only available via PDF.